The smell of fresh cooked pork sausages filled the air as we loaded our provisions into two canoes alongside the long wooden pier at Bare Point Marina. The four of us had already driven half an hour west from Kenora through an unkempt Indian reservation named Rat Portage, to the northeast corner of the Lake of the Woods. It would be another hour or more before we stopped for anything to eat.
On this particular Saturday afternoon, the world was bright and alive with the sound of children’s voices, dogs barking, and the ubiquitous hum of motor boat engines. None of us could fathom that our adventure would leave the land of living and descend into the darkness of the dead. This is a true story of how a few good Christians paddled across Bald Indian Bay to hear the ghostly voices of four dead miners at the bottom of Number Two shaft on Sultana Island.
My name is Russell Gainer. I led the August 4th, 2007 expedition to uncover the history and search for valuable relics in the bowels of Sultana Island. This is the story of a forgotten gold mine, and one that’s not completely abandoned. Accompanied by Trixie Blasé, Jasmine Edu and Chester Huff (and two four legged friends, Theo and Poncho), my intrepid crew or fortune hunters set out with the best intentions.
The plan was simple: by canoes it would take us forty minutes to cross the bay. We planned to explore Sultana Island all afternoon and then return before sunset. Our objective was to find the lost gold mine and rummage around through the remains of some of the original buildings. Trixie and I have been trained by the very best Dumpdiggers on how to dig century-old foundations to find important relics. It’s important to remember this mission started as a treasure hunt, not a séance.
Sultana is one of the most famous gold mines on the Lake of the Woods. The original claim was staked in November 1888 by Henry Bulmer, who sold the 27-acre property to a group of fifteen men who called themselves the Ontario Mining Company. This group did not even bother to register the claim. They hired a prospector and a mining engineer from New York to assay their purchase. Unfortunately, this "expert" wrote an adverse report in the summer of 1889 and because of this naysayer’s document, a third party named John F. Caldwell of Winnipeg managed to pick up the claim for a very reasonable price. He ignored the expert. He had visited the site himself and truly believed there was gold in the greenbelt quartz. He was right.
Mining operations commenced in the summer of 1892 when three small veins were discovered in the rock. Caldwell must have found enormous profit in his first six months, as he soon spent $30,000 erecting a five stamp mill on the island. This was a steam powered machine that crushed quartz to release gold nuggets from the ore. The machinery was imported from Chicago; its assembly was completed before Christmas. The stamps weighed 850 pounds each and were dropped eight inches 92 times a minute in the standard order, namely 1,5,2,4,3.
When we arrived at Sultana, we found the sandy beach deserted of all life and the shore full of driftwood – a beachcomber’s paradise. Beyond the dunes there was long grass and a dense forest that obscured all signs of any previous development. Beyond the trees we encountered a crumbling rock wall holding back a mass of rusty barrels that was bisected by a narrow trail that snaked its way up a steep incline. A set of stairs had been cut right into the rock.
Chester found a small chunk of dark red ore buried in the soil – a crumb of some really heavy metallic mineral. When I dug down into the rocky soil, I dredged up barrel hoops and bucket handles, thick square nails and rusty hinges. There was corrugated steel roofing lying in the grass beside the trail – all that remained of some structure, no doubt integral to the operation of the mine.
As we continued walking up the rise, the rest of the island came into view. At the top of the hill we each stared open mouthed at a century old rock cut that was the throat of the number two shaft. In the jaws of this stone cavity, we could see moss covered timbers set right into the rock. At one time these tree trunks had supported a sturdy platform on which miners might have worked the hoists. I threw a stone down into the darkness and we listened as it ricocheted off the sides of the passage. We waited almost fifteen seconds to hear the splash.
Unaware of any danger, I climbed down the rock wall to stand on the bed of timbers. Immediately I felt a blast of cold air rising from the cave. Although it was the heat of the summer, there was still plenty of ice down there in the darkness. Trixie was the first to hear it, dripping water echoed up the shaft. Between each drip there were other sounds, less natural.
In December 1899, Caldwell sold the mine. He’d made his fortune and was probably aware that further mining would not produce more bullion than he’d already liberated from the island. The new owners kept the staff: 12 miners, one blacksmith, five mill men and two cooks. Each were employed at $3.00 a day. The Sultana mine had been very profitable for many years; the new management was eager to maintain production – too eager.
When the gold seams faded away into the rock a few months later, the organization hired explosive experts and ferried a mass of low grade dynamite to the site. As the TNT was lowered down into the pit, there was an accident. History doesn’t record exactly what happened, but it does detail the deaths of four miners in 1901. Two men were buried in the rock at the bottom of the tunnel; it took a week’s digging to recover the bodies. Those are the two spirits whose cries forever resonate in the darkness of the mine.
Trixie bade us all to shut up and listen. For a moment, as I peered into the darkness of the abyss, I could hear the rope squeaking and then the faint echo of human voices; sounded like two men whispering soft warnings to each other. The air grew colder as their voices got louder; every member of the expedition was paralyzed with fear. We slowly backed away from the rock cut and then quickly ran down the hill, back to the boats. It was scary stuff. Fear pervaded our very beings. It wasn’t until we were back in our canoes and well away from shore that we could discuss the experience. We laughed about it then, but I think it’s safe to say that each of us was overcome with fear.
When I researched the mine at the Lake of the Woods Museum in Kenora, I learned that although the Sultana property was worked off and on for another thirty years, it was never as productive as it was before the accident. And it was riff with spooky incidents that speak of supernatural phenomenon. On two occasions there were dynamite boxes mysteriously emptied of all explosive material before they could be deployed. Equipment was found broken at the bottom of the pit and many new miners reported hearing voices calling out to them, begging for help. When I read about the voices, a cold shiver climbed up my spine; I had been there and heard those voices myself.